"VERDI CRIES" 10,000 MANIACS (1987)

For October, the Mental Jukebox is dialing it way back to the eighties and going deep. Deep cuts have always been an important element of music listening to me because they’re often the songs that resonate with me most. Deep cuts are usually the ones that the true fans appreciate most. I like my singles and hits, but I love my deep cuts.

Natalie Merchant’s lyrics during the 10,000 Maniacs years are absolute treasures. An underrated songwriter, I never understood why they weren’t bigger. I’ve always preferred those albums – especially In My Tribe and Our Time In Eden – much more than Merchant’s solo work although those albums got all the attention. One of the greatest treasures of them all is the last track on In My Tribe: “Verdi Cries”.

Few songs capture beauty and heartache as well as “Verdi Cries”. The song is steeped in an overwhelming sense of isolation, with the only thing accompanying the man in 119 is the music. The tale told by Merchant is beautifully written and brought to life by the strings: cello, viola and double bass. Even in my high schools, I sensed Merchant tugging heartstrings on this one which, almost always, is the best way to sing a song.

“The man in 119 takes his tea all alone. Mornings we all rise to wireless Verdi cries.”

"DON'T TALK" 10,000 MANIACS (1987)

For the next 30 days, I’ll be taking the #AprilAcrossAmerica challenge, picking one song a day as I make my way across the country and across genres at the same time.

Day 5: Jamestown, NY

When In My Tribe came out, I couldn’t stop playing it. Those songs ushered me into a different world that I could get lost in over and over again. “What’s the Matter Here?” and “Like the Weather” got all the recognition and airplay, well, at least on college rock stations. But the really good stuff revealed itself halfway through the album with Track 6, an unassuming, but peculiar song called “Don’t Talk”.

While every song was gold on In My Tribe, there was something a bit more magical about “Don’t Talk”. Each of the other tracks seemed to move along at one pace and were characterized by a single persona. But “Don’t Talk” shifted back and forth between three tempos. It was constructed with multiple movements. While most of the album had a very straight-ahead folk sound, this song took some more risks, marrying the aforementioned folk elements with a swirly, shoegaze-inspired sound.

“THE DRINK YOU DROWN YOUR TROUBLES IN IS THE TROUBLE YOU'RE IN NOW.”

"TOLERANCE" 10,000 MANIACS (1992)

I started Mental Jukebox nearly three years ago at the beginning of the pandemic. During this time, I’ve discovered new music, rediscovered old favorites and I’ve met passionate music fans around the world. And when things opened up, I kept on blogging. This month, the jukebox goes deeper. The term “deep cut” has multiple meanings. It can refer to lesser known album tracks from well-known artists. It can also refer to tracks from lesser known artists. This month, I’ll be featuring both types. #DeepCutsFeb

A big part of what made the 10,000 Maniacs sound work so well was the subtle, often rhythmic approaches to the guitar playing. The formula worked well because it put Natalie Merchant’s vocals and the song melodies in the spotlight. This is evident throughout their catalog, particularly on In My Tribe and Our Time In Eden, the album that allowed the band to break into the mainstream. But there was an anomaly on the album – a deep cut track and favorite of mine called “Tolerance.”

Our Time In Eden stretched deep: 13 tracks long. Even so, it showed no signs of letting up. The richness of the songwriting is evident. Track 10, “Tolerance”, didn’t follow the band’s traditional formula. The mix gives equal emphasis to Merchant’s vocals as it does to Robert Buck’s scorching guitar riff. “Tolerance” comes out out of the gate on a mission and rocks a little harder than what the band is used to. A delightful, unexpected facet to the band that seemed to work well – even as the band stepped out of their comfort zone.

“Hear it grow, hear it fade. The sound you're hearing, the sound you're fearing is the hate that parades up and down our streets, coming within bounds and within reach.”

"THESE ARE DAYS" 10,000 MANIACS (1992)

One of the most powerful things about music is that it is the soundtrack of our lives. Fellow music fanatic Sharon Hepworth started a music challenge on Twitter for the month of July. Each day, fans around the world will select a song from their life and describe what it means to us. These are my songs. #SoundtrackToYourLife

Day 24

Well, I certainly can’t share the soundtrack of my life without covering our wedding day. 10,000 Maniacs’ “These Are Days” is one of the most uplifting songs I’ve heard both recorded and live. I knew its beautiful, energetic sense of optimism had to appear at some point during our wedding. My wife Carol and I chose to include it in the ceremony as the recessional music. Well, I chose it, and she agreed. While my wife did some planning solo, and we did a ton of the prep together, the music selections were almost all mine.

“These Are Days” hails from my second favorite 10,000 Maniacs album. In My Tribe is tops in my book, but Our Time In Eden isn’t far behind in second place. The album sounds like a band that still has its sense of humbleness still intact. But it also sounds like a band that’s confident in its evolution. I love all the songs, but “These Are Days” is the one that stirs my emotions the most. Natalie Merchant sings with a sense of bewilderment. Buck – who co-wrote the song with Merchant – along with Drew, Gustafson and Augustyniak, ooze with merriment and wonder, each contributing signature instrumental elements to one of my favorite 10,000 Maniacs anthems.

“It's true that you are touched by something that will grow and bloom in you.”

"DON'T TALK" 10,000 MANIACS (1987)

For the second half of September, I’m putting my Mental Jukebox into a time machine, featuring the best songs on the best albums from the very best years of music. #70sThrough90sBestAlbum

When In My Tribe came out, I couldn’t stop playing it. Those songs ushered me into a different world that I could get lost in over and over again. “What’s the Matter Here?” and “Like the Weather” got all the recognition and airplay, well, at least on college rock stations. But the really good stuff revealed itself halfway through the album with Track 6, an unassuming, but peculiar song called “Don’t Talk”.

While every song was gold on In My Tribe, there was something a bit more magical about “Don’t Talk”. Each of the other tracks seemed to move along at one pace and were characterized by a single persona. But “Don’t Talk” shifted back and forth between three tempos. It was constructed with multiple movements. While most of the album had a very straight-ahead folk sound, this song took some more risks, marrying the aforementioned folk elements with a swirly, shoegaze-inspired sound.

“The drink you drown your troubles in is the trouble you're in now.”

"HEY JACK KEROUAC" 10,000 MANIACS (1987)

All these years later, In My Tribe is still one of my favorite albums because it’s so unpretentious. It’s not trying to impress you, but that’s exactly what makes it so impressive. “Hey Jack Kerouac” is a shining example of this. A song about some of the Beat generation luminaries, written and sung as if they were just ordinary people. When Natalie Merchant went solo, I think some of this magic was lost. That’s why I’ve always preferred the 10,000 Maniacs catalog more.

“The hip flask slinging madman, steaming cafe flirts,
nights in Chinatown, howling at night.”